• Store
  • Sign-up
  • Sign-in
Menu
Practising the Piano
  • Home
  • Resources
    • Multimedia eBook Series
    • Online Academy
    • Video Lessons
    • Annotated Study Editions
    • Repertoire Resources
    • Piano Technique Resources
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Online Events
    • London Piano Courses
    • Practice Clinics
    • Online Performance Workshops
  • Blog
      • Practising
      • Learning Pieces
      • Technique
      • Performing
      • Teaching
      • Archive
  • About Us
    • Help & Support
    • Contact us
HomePractisingDon’t Try This at Home! – Mechanical Aids to Practice

Don’t Try This at Home! – Mechanical Aids to Practice

By Graham Fitch, 2013-12-20 Posted in: Practising

If you were a student at the Stuttgart Conservatory in the mid 1800‘s during the reign of Sigismund Lebert and Ludwig Stark, you would have had to practise a strict regime of finger exercises, preferably with the aid of a hand rail (a device attached to the piano enabling the player to rest their wrists on it). The point was to achieve everything with the fingers and the wrist, the rest of the arm remaining quiet and passive. The elbow was to stay close to the body and only the forearm was supposed to move if the hands needed to move outwards. The basic finger touch was known as the “hammer touch”, where each finger was lifted as high as possible and then slammed into the key fortissimo (with no help from the arm). When the key was released, the finger had to return to its high position. Lebert and Stark’s method book was first published in 1858 and was widely disseminated across the world, successful for over a century.

lebert and stark

Piano teachers at the time were trying to find ways of tackling the more powerful pianos and the different styles of music being written, and this was Lebert and Stark’s response – needless to say, crippling injuries were reported. A form of the hammer touch is still being taught to this day, and there are well-known and celebrated pianists who swear by this approach. The are plenty of others who would consider this harmful and unnatural, especially if the finger curls up tightly as it is lifted.

It was during the mid 19th century that we see a split between technical and musical work, so that it was possible (and prevalent) for the player to separate pure mechanics from musical thought and expression. It led to a group of piano students who had no real lively interest in music, but who were concerned solely with becoming showmen at the piano. Mechanical teaching aids, notably Logier’s Chiroplast, Herz’s Dactylion and Kalkbrenner’s Hand Guide (a simplification of the Chiroplast), were designed to speed up acquiring a virtuoso technique and were advocated by many teachers and players. Nowadays, such devices are generally considered not only futile but downright injurious and actually ridiculous. I have a feeling this period in the history of piano playing is why some teachers today have a dread of any type of mechanical practice, but as I have said before some mechanical work is necessary in the building of a pianist and how we do things is paramount. What we do has to be done intelligently and with care and attention, and without strong and reliable fingers no serious playing is possible. It is the fixation on the fingers and the blocking off of rotary and other arm movements where problems occur.

Regarding the Dactylion, it is widely believed that this terrible device was responsible for Schumann’s hand injury, but for more insight into this do read Jura Margulis’ excellent article on the subject.

If you are not familiar with the work of Natalia Strelchenko, here she is demonstrating the explaining Kalkbrenner’s guide rail on a period piano (the notion that pianists were once actually expected to practise like this fills me with horror).

It is important to add here that many of the studies from the Finger School and other method books from the period are musically interesting and can still be of pedagogical value. We can select from the vast range of material that is available and adapt it for our own use. This might mean ignoring the technical instructions given by the composer, and certainly the specified number of repetitions!

In conclusion, a caveat from a writer of the time, E. S. Kelley, concerning mechanical practice:

Some even go so far as to assert that it is better to study unmusical exercises, for if the pupil plays that which pleases him, his attention will be diverted from the position of his hands. Dr. Hans von Bülow, while commenting upon the effects of practising monotonous five-finger exercises, maintains that the flexibility thus gained is acquired at the cost of musical intelligence….Involuntarily the performer loses all thought of what he is playing. The great lack of charm and interest of the task produces absent-mindedness, and, finally, utter thoughtlessness. The player becomes a mere machine, forgetting that he has to be engineer at the same time, without whose care its progress, if not stopped immediately, will be greatly impeded. (E.S. Kelley, “Pianoforte Study: The Method Employed in the Conservatory at Stuttgart”, 169)

If you want to read more about the history of piano technique, Part 2 of my eBook Series, Practising the Piano is now available. Please see below for details of how to get your copy.

Practising the Piano Part 2

Buy all three volumes of Practising The Piano Part 2  for 25% off the individual volume prices or click here to view the full Practising the Piano eBook Series catalogue.

[prod_btns code=”part2bundle” title=” “]

There will be no posts for the next two weeks as I shall be taking a seasonal holiday. Festive felicitations to all my readers!

Tags: Dactylionfinger schoolhammer touchhammer-fingerHenri HerzhistoryJura MargulisKalkbrennerLebertLebert and StarkLogier's Chiroplastmechanical aidsNatalia Strelchenkorotary movementStarkStuttgart Conservatorytechniquetheory

Related Posts

Focus in Practice

Focus in Practice

By Graham Fitch, 2014-11-29
Posted in: Blog

As a teacher, my chief aim is to assist my students in playing more freely and expressively. A big part of that process is helping them unlock their unique musical personality and equipping them with a solid technical foundation. There has been much discussion of late in the piano networks…

Read More

Tags: EvocoGrigory Koganheinrich neuhausLebert and StarkMuzio ClementiNina SvetlanovaSchumann CarnavalSergei RachmaninovVladimir HorowitzWanda Landowska
Focus in Practice
Technique Library & Resources Preview

Technique Library & Resources Preview

By Graham Fitch, 2020-02-13
Posted in: Technique

Following our announcements last year regarding upcoming projects and content, we’ve been hard at work on a collection of modules on piano technique, the first of which is now available on the Online Academy - with others to follow thereafter. These initial modules will cover technical fundamentals, scales and arpeggios…

Read More

Tags: forearm rotationpiano scales and arpeggiospiano techniquetechnique
Technique Library & Resources Preview
A Practical Guide to Forearm Rotation

A Practical Guide to Forearm Rotation

By Graham Fitch, 2020-04-23
Posted in: Technique

In my work as a teacher, I regularly encounter pianists even at the advanced level who ask me for my special exercises to “strengthen” their fingers. Initially they react with disappointment when I tell them I don’t have any such exercises nor do I believe in them, and that their…

Read More

Tags: Dorothy Taubmanfinger schoolforearm rotationpassageworkpiano techniquetechnique
A Practical Guide to Forearm Rotation
Tied Up

Tied Up

By Graham Fitch, 2013-09-13
Posted in: Practising

I was at Steinway Hall here in London yesterday making another series of video demonstrations for Pianist Magazine. One of the demonstrations was on how to manage trills. If we investigate the mechanics of a trill, we find it is two repeated notes in rapid alternation with each other. Releasing…

Read More

Tags: Bjs bachChopinetudeornamentsrepeated notesScarlattisonatatied notestrills
Tied Up
Inventing Exercises

Inventing Exercises

By Graham Fitch, 2011-09-17
Posted in: Practising

One thing I can say for certain is that we are all different. When it comes down to rituals in practising, there is nothing more personal than what we do to warm up. I have some colleagues who feel driven to go through their lengthy warm-up regime before they will…

Read More

Tags: beethovenexercisesinventionpractising the pianoSchumann
Inventing Exercises
Focus Your Practice with Zigzag

Focus Your Practice with Zigzag

By Graham Fitch, 2017-01-26
Posted in: Practice tools, Practising

I use a form of practice for myself that I call zigzag practice. It helps test and strengthen my memory by keeping me incredibly focussed, but there's no way it will work unless I am concentrating fully. I also recommend it to my students, and I have noticed it has…

Read More

Tags: Handel Sonatina in Gzigzag
Focus Your Practice with Zigzag

Previous Post

The History of Piano Technique: Studies and Exercises

Next Post

Top Ten Tips to Maximise Your Practice

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Sign-up To Our Mailing List!

Sign-up to our email newsletter for free resources, news updates and special offers!

TOPICS

  • Practising
  • Learning Pieces
  • Technique
  • Performing
  • Teaching

LINKS

  • Online Academy
  • Informance
  • Help & Support
  • Contact Us

© 2023 Practising the Piano All Rights Reserved

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Privacy Policy
  • T&Cs