• Store
  • Sign-up
  • Sign-in
Menu
Practising the Piano
  • Home
  • Resources
    • Multimedia eBook Series
    • Online Academy
    • Video Lessons
    • Annotated Study Editions
    • Repertoire Resources
    • Piano Technique Resources
    • Amateur Piano Groups & Clubs
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Online Events
    • London Piano Courses
    • Practice Clinics
    • Online Performance Workshops
  • Blog
      • Practising
      • Learning Pieces
      • Technique
      • Performing
      • Teaching
      • Archive
  • About Us
    • Help & Support
    • Contact us
HomeInspirationThe Myth of the Instant Fix

The Myth of the Instant Fix

By Graham Fitch, 2014-07-11 Posted in: Inspiration

I have admitted before that I like to stand outside institutional practice room doors and listen to what is going on inside. So often the practiser is just hammering through their piece at full speed, and triple fortissimo. When they make a mistake they hack away at it until it finally yields, and simply move on. What they have actually practised is getting it wrong three or four times in a row and right on the fifth attempt. What, then, are the chances of getting it right the first time in the context of the flow of the piece? I’m no statistician, but I would have thought very slim indeed. They are far more likely to get it wrong again until they take steps to get to the root of what derailed them in the first place. This takes conscious thought, self reflection and a spirit of enquiry.

Remember – practice makes permanent, and whatever you repeatedly do will become ingrained.

Instead of thinking of the mistake as an enemy we throttle until we destroy it, we might instead consider it a messenger. The mistake is there to tell us something, and we can learn from it.

  • What went wrong, and where exactly did it go wrong? If the derailment or slip happened in bar 28, was it something just before that caused it?
  • Was it a lapse of memory or concentration, or a technical problem?
  • Or was it that I haven’t really settled on a workable fingering, or organised my pedalling?
  • Am I really sure exactly what is happening in that bar, or am I winging it?
  • Does my LH really know the middle notes of that chord? How would I label that chord, and what is its function?

A lack of perception is so often responsible for errors that the player is quick to dismiss as technical. It’s easier just to blame it on the fingers (our servants) rather than our brain (the master). How many times in Brahms’ A major Intermezzo from the op. 118 set have I heard stumbles in the following parallel passages (please imagine a key signature of three sharps, a time signature of 3/4, and Andante teneramente):

1.  Brahms 1

2.  Brahms 2

 

We need to be crystal clear on the differences between these two places, and to decide what Brahms may have meant.

  • How might the long phrase marking in 1 v. the shorter phrase markings in 2 alter the way we play them? In 1, I would take no time over the downbeat of the last bar nor would I stress it – one seamless phrase. In 2, we give this downbeat an agogic accent.
  • In 2, I would give space to the chromatic descent (F#, F, E) in the alto part, and to the appoggiaturas in the middle parts on the 2nd beat of the middle bar. I would certainly make sure to pedal carefully here, so as not to leave the dissonance and the resolution swimming in the same pedal. The thickening of the texture in 2 surely needs a bit more time and space.
  • What do these changes in 2 mean? My feeling – and it is a personal one – is that 1 is more optimistic and in 2 the optimism is tinged with yearning. In his heart of hearts, Brahms remembers he didn’t get what he really wanted.
  • In both examples, I would take care that the second note of the slurred pairs is always softer and lighter than the first. This lends the piece its throbbing, sighing and sobbing nature.

This Intermezzo is filled with subtle beauties such as these, and they take some time to reveal themselves to us. Perhaps I should write a post on it – if I did, it would be a very long one.

*** *** *** *** ***

In Part 3 of my ebook series, I explore scale and arpeggio playing in depth. Included are many ideas for practising, as well as rhythm charts, practice charts, other interactive features and video demonstrations.

Preview or Buy Practising the Piano Part 3

Click on “Preview” for a free preview or on “Buy” to purchase Part 3 of Practising The Piano now.
[prod_btns code=”ptpp3v1″ title=””]
Click here for the full series bundle:
[prod_btns code=”ptpp123bundle” title=” “]

For more information, and the catalogue to purchase individual parts, click here.

***   ***   ***   ***   ***

As part of my research for Part 4 (on performance), I have devised a short (very short, actually) survey – Performance Anxiety among Pianists, the results of which I will collate and include in the publication. I would be most grateful if you would take two or three minutes to complete the survey. It really is very brief, and you will be completely anonymous. Whether you are a professional pianist, a piano student or play for your own pleasure your opinion and comments count.

Let me thank you very much indeed in advance for your time and input!

Take the survey

 

 

Tags: Brahms Intermezzo in A op. 118

Related Posts

On Singing

On Singing

By Graham Fitch, 2017-06-15
Posted in: Inspiration

I had always sung in choirs and choruses from my childhood to the end of my student days, and one of the highlights of my week as a postgraduate student in New York was my voice lesson. I came away from it feeling energised and exhilarated (as well as hungry)…

Read More

Tags: Brahms Intermezzo in A op. 118CPE BachLeon FleisherRobert Schumann Advice to Young Musicians
On Singing
Spot the Difference

Spot the Difference

By Graham Fitch, 2013-03-01
Posted in: General tips

I used to like those spot-the-difference cartoons that appeared in the comics I read as a lad. At first glance, both images look the same but you have to look closer until you find a specified number of differences between the two. Whenever I teach Brahms' Intermezzo in A from…

Read More

Tags: BrahmsBrahms Intermezzo in A op. 118Practising The Piano eBook Seriesspot the difference
Spot the Difference
Brahms’s Buried Treasure

Brahms’s Buried Treasure

By Graham Fitch, 2020-05-14
Posted in: Learning Pieces

The six Klavierstücke that make up the op. 118 set were published in 1893 and dedicated to Brahms’ lifelong friend, Clara Schumann. In the late summer of 1893, Brahms sent Clara manuscripts of the pieces, which thrilled her. She wrote to him how remarkable it was that he had managed…

Read More

Tags: annotated study editionBrahmsBrahms IntermezzoBrahms Intermezzo in A op. 118Clara Schumann
Brahms’s Buried Treasure
Keyboard Conversations with Fred Karpoff

Keyboard Conversations with Fred Karpoff

By Informance, 2023-05-18
Posted in: Blog, Inspiration

Video conversation between Fred Karpoff and Graham Fitch discussing teachers who inspired them, their online projects and approaches to technique.

Read More

Tags: ann scheinforearm rotationfred karpoffJulian Martinkeyboard conversationsLeon Fleishertechnique
Keyboard Conversations with Fred Karpoff
The Transcriptions of Alexander Siloti

The Transcriptions of Alexander Siloti

By Graham Fitch, 2019-10-31
Posted in: General, Inspiration

As an impressionable teenager I was awestruck by the incredible sounds Emil Gilels managed to draw from the piano in Alexander Siloti’s gorgeous Prelude in B minor, a transcription of Bach’s E minor Prelude that appears both in the Clavier-Büchlein für Wilhelm Friedemann Bach and as Prelude no. 10 from…

Read More

Tags: alexander siloti
2 Comments
The Transcriptions of Alexander Siloti
Schumann’s Romance in F Sharp

Schumann’s Romance in F Sharp

By Graham Fitch, 2019-10-03
Posted in: Inspiration, Learning Pieces

In 1839, Clara Wieck received a Christmas present from her fiancé, Robert Schumann - a set of three Romances (published with some slight alterations the following year as opus 28). She was particularly smitten with the second one, describing it as “the most beautiful love duet”. Fast forward several decades…

Read More

Tags: Clara SchumannEmil GilelsHarold BauerRobert SchumannRomance in F sharp major
Schumann’s Romance in F Sharp

Previous Post

New Practising the Piano website launched!

Next Post

The Countdown to Your Diploma Exam

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Sign-up To Our Mailing List!

Sign-up to our email newsletter for free resources, news updates and special offers!

TOPICS

  • Practising
  • Learning Pieces
  • Technique
  • Performing
  • Teaching

LINKS

  • Online Academy
  • Informance
  • Help & Support
  • Contact Us

© 2025 Practising the Piano All Rights Reserved

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Privacy Policy
  • T&Cs
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website.OkMore Information